Moral Panics, Sex Panics, and the Production of a Lebanese Nation

of 3
25 views
PDF
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Document Description
Moral Panics, Sex Panics, and the Production of a Lebanese Nation
Document Share
Document Tags
Document Transcript
  8/26/2014Moral Panics, Sex Panics and the Production of A Lebanese Nationhttp://www.jadaliyya.com/pages/index/16570/moral-panics-sex-panics-and-the-production-of-a-le1/4 [Snapshots from Lebanese Ministry of Tourism Videos,Compiled by Maya Mikdashi'] Moral Panics, Sex Panics and the Production of A LebaneseNation You, Rasha Khoury and 542 othersrecommend this.   Tweet 49 In the past few months sex panics and moral panics,centered on gendered bodies and abuses, have rockedLebanon. In this article I want to revisit three of thesepanics: photos of a semi-nude Lebanese OlympicSkier’s body and reactions to it; the impunity of wifemurderers and wife abusers; and the razing of a Syrianmakeshift refugee camp after (ultimately false)accusations of sex abuse by a camp resident of amentally disabled Lebanese man. I bring these threecases together in order to think about the political workthat the moral/sex panic does  in making and remakingLebanese national identity and in articulating itsgendered architecture. I do so in order toavoid thinking each separately under the rubrics of sexual discrimination or abuse in  Lebanon. Good Bodies, Bad Bodies Jackie Chamoun is a skier representing Lebanon at theWinter 2014 Olympics. Her qualification for the premier international sporting event is itself a success, given the lack of training infrastructures and support for athletes (particularly females) in Lebanon. Recently, photos a friend of Chamoun’s took for a calendar, featured the athlete in various poses (though not full frontal) and topless. The photosspread through the Internet like wildfire. In response, the Caretaker Lebanese minister for Youth and Sports, FaisalKarami, ordered an investigation into the photos. He stated that they, and by extension Chamoun, were damaging tothe country’s image. In a country with chronic youth unemployment and a widely corrupt professional sports system, aswell as the lack of support for sports and youth more broadly, it was these photos that were just too much for the goodminister. Almost immediately, people reacted, both positively and negatively, to Karami’s announcement. But whatwas the image of Lebanon that Karami wanted to protect, and why was the site of a female athletic body—andathletes, given that their bodies are their work, are rightly proud and confident in them— so threatening to that image?Lebanese activists rightly pointed out that campaigns marketing everything from veterinary services to the country itself (in Ministry of Tourism advertisements) rely on female nudity and the consumption of the sexualized female body. Sextourism is a large industry in Lebanon, and the trafficking of women for sexual labor is an open and largely unremarkedupon phenomenon, as is the sexual abuse of domestic/slave labor. Furthermore, male athletic bodies are often instates of undress, as they rip or lift their shirts after scoring in a football or basketball match—and yet they do notdamage the country’s image. In fact, the amount of nudity displayed by Chamoun in the photo shoot was no more thanany male swimmer in an athletic competition, in or out of the pool.The different weighting of female and male bodies, of nudity, and the uneven distribution of national identity and honor across this gendered divide deserves attention. Thefact that Chamoun is female, and thus “obscene” when topless, is exactly the “problem.” Nudity is not the issue here. Female nudity—outside the confines of consumerism or state driven tourism—is. Chamoun’s displaying of her body,the very thing that enables her to compete at such high levels, sealed her fall from national grace. It also revealed theways that gendered bodies constitute the seams of the nation as it produces and markets itself. Feb 22 2014by Maya Mikdashi  8/26/2014Moral Panics, Sex Panics and the Production of A Lebanese Nationhttp://www.jadaliyya.com/pages/index/16570/moral-panics-sex-panics-and-the-production-of-a-le2/4 Chamoun was supposed to be a “good girl,” a hero for Lebanese to look up to as she represented her country at theOlympics. She was supposed to represent the nation as the nation wished to present itself. Other contexts—such asdrives for tourism or the phenomenon of Lebanese music videos—require “bad girls.” Crucially, both “good girls” and“bad girls” are not supposed to be sovereign over their bodies and the representation of them. It is the (masculinist)state and the economy, both of which are said to be in service of “the nation” that decides the form and content of thatrepresentation. After all, why would Lebanese women have sovereignty over the representation of their bodies whenthey lack sovereignty over their bodies in Lebanese law and are instead legal appendages to male citizens? Dead Wives, Protected Husbands Recent cases and reports of husbands killing their wives further clarify how Lebanese law renders female citizens aslegal appendages of their male counterparts. As of February 17 th , husbands reportedly killed twenty-five women wereidentified in Lebanon. The actual number of such crimes is undoubtedly higher. Not one of these husbands has beencharged with a crime (yet). Much activist and journalistic attention has focused on the urgent need to pass a domesticviolence law that protects women and children in Lebanon from physical, emotional, and sexual abuse. Political andreligious leaders have refused to pass a law that includes the criminalization of marital rape. A truncated domesticviolence law has similarly stalled in the political paralysis of the halls of the government. Even if such a law were topass, however, it would do little to ameliorate the legal, social,and economic inequalities that tie wives and daughtersto their husbands and families and make them more vulnerable to abuse. For example, custody laws make it almostimpossible for a woman to divorce her husband and retain custody over her children, even if she can prove a pattern of abuse against her. Faced with these impossible choices, many women endure abusive marriages in order to remainwith their children. Divorce law largely favors males, across all Christian and Muslim personal status laws. Criminallaw, meanwhile, sets different standards for male and female adultery, in addition to continuing to except marital rapefrom punishment and allowing rapists to propose marriage to their victims and receive lesser punishments.Furthermore, the presence of a domestic law will not magically make the reporting of domestic violence moreacceptable or available. It will not make the police take such calls seriously and stop them from deferring to husbands.It will not make them recognize that one, abuse is  abuse and that two, abuse is not a “private” issue to be dealt with athome and between families—the very context within which abuse is happening.Feminists know that appealing to the state and its police has always been a double-edged sword. After all, the stateand its police the security forces are masculinist and patriarchal structures. The extent to which they are sexistinstitutions interested in protecting male privilege over female bodies is clear every time a wife is murdered or raped or abused and politicians and the police refuse to consider this a punishable offense. The patriarchal nation, and themasculinist state reproduced themselves at these moments. Women represent the nation, but men—who areproduced as male citizens in part through their legal mastery over female bodies, constitute it. Activist and familydemands for accountability as well as the calls for a domestic violence law are much needed interventions. Together they confront the legal, social, bureaucratic and economic ways that female citizens are produced as always in relationto their family status. Sex Panics and the Borders of the Nation In December of 2013, allegations were made that residents of a Syrian refugee tent settlement in eastern Lebanon hadraped a mentally disabled Lebanese man. The Lebanese army raided the refugee encampment and arrested dozensof men for questioning. They did not find any evidence of the attack. A medical official testified that he had found noevidence of rape on or in the alleged victim. Undeterred, members of neighboring villages raided the refugee campsiteand burned much of it down—displacing the Syrian refugees once again. The Lebanese citizens who had made theapparently false accusation and then forcibly displaced the Syrian refugees were not charged or investigated for anycriminal or civil offense.This incident demonstrated the ways that distinctions between “Lebanese” and “Syrian refugee” are articulated acrossunderstandings of violable bodies. A false accusation of Syrian male-Lebanese male rape produced a sex panic that inturn allowed the violation of Syrian bodies. The constitutive outside of the Lebanese nation has historically been thePalestinian refugee and the domestic laborer. Today with over one million Syrian refugees seeking refuge in Lebanon—often in impoverished and disenfranchised areas of the country—Syrian bodies are tasked with articulating nationaldifference. The sexual abuse by Lebanese (and rich tourists) of Syrian women and girls is endemic. Male and femaleprostitution has become a primary way for Syrian refugees to earn a living. Neither of these phenomena unleashes sexpanics. In this framework, Syrian bodies become that which can be violated by Lebanese. The fact that it was alleged  8/26/2014Moral Panics, Sex Panics and the Production of A Lebanese Nationhttp://www.jadaliyya.com/pages/index/16570/moral-panics-sex-panics-and-the-production-of-a-le3/4 that the accusation of rape was concocted in order   to remove the Syrians from their villages only underscores the waysthat sex panics license violent convulsions that re-entrench who is inside and outside the nation. Thus the accusationthat a Lebanese male  body was violated enabled the violation of an entire Syrian refugee community. Such logic—thatnational boundaries can be articulated across availability for violence—is also at play when it comes to domestic labor.In a similar fashion, the draft domestic violence law—in its present form at least—does not address violence againstdomestic labor. This omission reproduces foreign labor as “outside” the imagined Lebanese heteronormative family as-nation.Moral panics and sex panics do not (only) reflect a country’s social or political realities, they articulate and help shapethem—especially at moments of deep civil and political unrest, a context that defines today’s Lebanon. Chamoun, themurder of wives by husbands, and the violation of a Syrian refugee camp, each articulate how the Lebanese state andnation define and represent themselves across gendered architectures of citizenship and non-citizenship. Lebanesefemale bodies are legally tied to male bodies. They are tasked with the marketing of the nation—the good, asexualbody and the bad, sexually available body are always female.What holds this gendered architecture together as nation are constitutive “outsiders”—domestic and migrant labor,Syrian and Palestinian refugees. Lebanon must protect “their women” (and feminized men) from these outsiders asthey are simultaneously made available for violation by members of the Lebanese nation. At each of these moments,moral panics, and sex panics bring into focus the ways that both Lebanese citizenship and national imaginaries aregendered and the ways that sexual difference operates and is operationalized politically. Thinking these momentstogether, rather than as separate moments of sexism, racism, classism or xenophobia, allows us to interrogate thenation as it produces itself, particularly at times when the nation itself is said to be in crisis. Latest posts in SaC :  Can Palestinian Men be Victims? Gendering Israel's War on Gaza   The Empty Promise of State-Sponsored Feminism in the ArabianPeninsulaIf you prefer, email your comments to info@jadaliyya.com. Jadaliyya  About JadaliyyaJadaliyya TeamContributorsContact Information Contributions Submission GuidelinesRelease FormPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service Pages/Sections CultureReportsReviewsInterviewsJad NavigationO.I.L. Features Roundtables Facebook social plugin  Also post on Facebook Posting as Maya Mikdashi (Change)  Comment  Add a comment... Sabiha Al  · · Top Commenter · School of Oriental and African StudiesThank you Jadaliyya for publishing my article! Seriously????Reply · Like · Follow Post · Edited · February 28 at 2:56pm Follow
Similar documents
View more...
Search Related
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks
SAVE OUR EARTH

We need your sign to support Project to invent "SMART AND CONTROLLABLE REFLECTIVE BALLOONS" to cover the Sun and Save Our Earth.

More details...

Sign Now!

We are very appreciated for your Prompt Action!

x